ABSTRACT:
OBJECTIVE The objective of the present study was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of superior
capsular reconstruction (SCR) using fascia lata allograft.
METHODS A prospective case series of 15 patients with irreparable supraspinatus tear who underwent
SCR using fascia lata allograft. The American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) scale
at 12 months after surgery was the primary outcome. The University of California Los
Angeles (UCLA), Constant-Murley, and Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation (SANE) scales,
in addition to the range of motion, were secondary outcomes. Radiological parameters
were also evaluated by simple radiographs and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
RESULTS Fifteen patients completed 12 months of postoperative follow-up. The ASES score increased
from 34.0 to 73.0 (p= 0.005). The UCLA, Constant-Murley, and SANE scales also showed statistically significant
differences (p= 0.001; p= 0.005; and p= 0.046). In the evaluation of range of motion, there was improvement in elevation
and in external rotation (95 to 140°, p= 0.003; 30 to 60°, p= 0.007). Six patients (40%) had complete graft healing. The clinical outcomes were
significantly higher in the patients who presented graft healing.
CONCLUSIONS Superior capsular reconstruction using a fascia lata allograft is a safe and effective
procedure in short follow-up. Level of Evidence IV; Therapeutic Study; Case Series.
Keywords: rotator cuff injuries/surgery; shoulder joint; joint capsule; fascia lata/transplantation; treatment outcome.
RESUMO:
OBJETIVO O objetivo do presente estudo foi avaliar a eficácia e a segurança da reconstrução
capsular superior (RCS) com a utilização do aloenxerto de fáscia lata.
MÉTODOS Uma série de casos prospectivos de 15 pacientes com ruptura irreparável do supraespinhal
foi submetida a RCS com aloenxerto de fáscia lata, sendo adotada como desfecho primário
a escala American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES, na sigla em inglês) aos 12 meses
do pós-operatório. Como desfechos secundários, foram adotadas as escalas da University
of California Los Angeles (UCLA, na sigla em inglês), Constant-Murley, e Single Assessment
Numeric Evaluation (SANE, na sigla em inglês), além da amplitude de movimento. Os
parâmetros radiológicos também foram avaliados por radiografias simples e ressonância
magnética (RM).
RESULTADOS Quinze pacientes completaram 12 meses de acompanhamento pós-operatório. O escore ASES
aumentou de 34,0 para 73,0 (p= 0,005). As escalas UCLA, Constant-Murley e SANE também apresentaram diferenças estatisticamente
significativas (p= 0,001; p= 0,005; e p= 0,046). Na avaliação da amplitude de movimento, houve melhora na elevação e rotação
externa (95 a 140°, p= 0,003; 30 a 60°, p= 0,007). Seis pacientes (40%) tiveram cicatrização completa do enxerto. Os desfechos
clínicos foram significativamente maiores nos pacientes que apresentaram cicatrização
do enxerto.
CONCLUSÕES A RCS com aloenxerto de fáscia lata é um procedimento seguro e eficaz com um curto
acompanhamento de tempo. Nível de evidência IV; Estudo Terapêutico; Série de casos.
Palavras-chave: lesões do manguito rotador/cirurgia; articulação do ombro; cápsula articular; fáscia lata/transplante; resultado do tratamento.
FIGURES
| Citation: Beraldo RA, Gracitelli MEC, Malavolta EA, Assunção JH, Silva FBAe, Ferreira Neto AA. Treatment of Irreparable Rotator Cuff Tears: Superior Capsular Reconstruction with Fascia Lata Allograft. 57(05):876. doi:10.1055/s-0041-1732389 |
|
Conflict of interests The authors have no conflict of interests to declare. |
|
Work developed in the Shoulder and Elbow Group of the Institute of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Hospital das Clínicas, Faculty of Medicine, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil. |
| Received: October 21 2020; Accepted: February 11 2021 |
INTRODUCTION
Rotator cuff tear is a common condition, affecting ∼ 20% of the population.1 The surgical treatment for this lesion usually has significant clinical improvement.2 However, healing failures are frequent, with retears in 27% of the cases.3 The treatment of massive rotator cuff tears is particularly challenging, because the repair and its consequent healing are hampered by tendon retraction, muscle atrophy, and fatty degeneration.3 There is still no consensus for the treatment of irreparable supraspinatus tears, especially in young patients.
Mihata et al.4,5 described a procedure for superior capsular reconstruction (SCR) in patients with massive supraspinatus tears that aimed at restoring the upper stability of the glenohumeral joint and, thus, re-establishing the function of the remaining rotator cuff. Originally, the technique used autologous fascia lata for the graft.4 To reduce patient morbidity and surgical time, decellularized human dermis has gained popularity in SCR surgeries.6 To date, no clinical study has used the fascia lata allograft for SCR. Using this graft would have some advantages, including decreased patient morbidity, shorter surgical time, and adequate graft resistance.7
The aim of the present study is to evaluate the clinical results and healing of SCR. Our hypothesis is that SCR with fascia lata allograft has good clinical results, especially when there is graft healing.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study Design and Population Studied
Fifteen patients underwent SCR in a prospective cohort study. All patients were treated in the same institution and agreed to sign the informed consent form (CAAE-62105616.4.0000.0068).
We included patients with symptoms of pain or functional deficit and with a diagnosis of massive tear of the supraspinatus tendon, classified as grade 2, 3 or 4 of fatty degeneration, according to Goutallier et al.8 In addition, all patients had active external rotation > 0°.
Patients with full-thickness subscapularis tear with type 3 or 4 fatty degeneration, patients with rotator cuff arthropathy classified as Hamada et al.9 grade 5, and patients with previous shoulder injuries, such as brachial plexus injuries, proximal fractures of the humerus, and treated for active infection, were not included. Cases in which repair of the supraspinatus tendon was possible or cases in which repair of the subscapularis tendon was not possible were excluded.
Intervention
The surgeries were performed by the same shoulder and elbow surgeon with 11 years of experience [blinded]. Fascia lata allografts from the tissue bank were used, according to the standard collection protocol of the institution.
The procedure followed the steps described by Mihata et al.,4,10 but with a single-row fixation technique, previously described by the authors [blinded]. All cases were operated using an arthroscopic technique with the patient positioned in lateral decubitus with the arm abducted at 30°. Biceps tenotomy, bursectomy and acromioplasty were done in all cases. Subscapular tears were repaired when there was any partial or complete tear. Patients in whom the supraspinatus tendon was repairable were excluded from the study.
The first step of the SCR consisted of preparing the upper region of the glenoid and greater tuberosity and creating the accessory portals. Two portals, anterosuperior and posterosuperior, were made for the insertion of the anchors into the greater tubercle. The Neviaser portal, which allows the insertion of the posterior anchor into the glenoid and permits graft traction via a double pulley system, was also made. The anterior anchor of the glenoid was introduced through the anterior portal. All the anchors used were 5 mm, metallic, and double-loaded.
Next, a graft of the appropriate size was prepared, having to be folded 3 to 4 times to reach a thickness of 6 to 8 mm (►Fig. 1). The distances between the anchors were used to determine the location of the graft stitches (►Fig. 2).
The subsequent step consisted of fixation of the graft to the glenoid by performing an outside-in double pulley suture, in which the graft was pulled by the anchor threads through the medial Neviaser portal. After medial and lateral fixation of the graft, simple sutures were performed between the graft and the infraspinatus tendon11 (►Fig. 3).
Postoperative Follow-up
Rehabilitation followed the same protocol as that of rotator cuff repair. Patients were instructed to use an abduction pillow sling for 6 weeks. After 4 weeks, the patients underwent passive movement therapy, and active movement therapy was started after the 6th week. Twelve weeks after surgery, exercises to strengthen the rotator cuff and the stabilizing musculature of the scapula were started.
Outcomes
The ASES scale applied 12 months after surgery was adopted as the primary outcome. The secondary outcomes adopted were the Constant-Murley, UCLA, and SANE scales; active range of motion was assessed with the patient in the standing position. Elevation, external, and internal rotation were evaluated. All measurements were performed with a goniometer, except internal rotation, which was assessed according to the position of the hand of the patient in relation to the vertebral spinous processes and subsequently converted to continuous numbers using a scale from 1 to 19 (T1 to T12 = 1 to 12; L1 to L5 = 13 to 17; sacrum = 18; and greater trochanter = 19). The distance between the acromion and the head of the humerus was evaluated by the Ellman12 method; assessment of the healing of the graft was performed through MRI 6 months after the procedure; as well as complications and reoperations. The graft was considered “unhealed” when it showed signs of discontinuity in two or more T1- and T2 continuous oblique coronal cuts. The scales and range of motion were assessed by an independent evaluator, and the MRIs were evaluated by a musculoskeletal radiologist.
Statistical Analysis
We subjected the continuous variables to the evaluation of normality through the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test and of homogeneity through the Levene test. The continuous data were expressed as mean, median, standard deviation (SD) and interquartile range. The categorical variables were expressed as absolute value and percentage. The comparison between the different variables before and after treatment was performed using the chi-squared or the Fisher exact test for categorical variables and the Wilcoxon test for continuous variables. We used IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows version 21.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NU, USA) for data analysis, with a significance level of 5%.
RESULTS
Twenty patients were initially included for SCR using fascia lata allograft between March 2017 and February 2018. During surgery, 5 patients were excluded from the study after complete rotator cuff repair. No patients were lost to follow-up. Thus, 15 patients received the surgical treatment proposed. The general characteristics of the sample are shown in ►Table 1.
| Cases | |
|---|---|
| Gender, n (%) | |
| Male | 8 (53.3) |
| Female | 7 (46.7) |
| Age (years old) | |
| Mean (SD) | 60.6 (8.56) |
| Smoker, n (%) | |
| Yes | 1 (6.7) |
| Ex-smoker | 4 (26.7) |
| No | 11 (66.6) |
| Diabetes, n (%) | |
| Yes | 4 (26.7) |
| No | 11 (73.3) |
| Side affected, n (%) | |
| Right | 13 (86.7) |
| Left | 2 (13.3) |
| Dominant side affected, n (%) | |
| Yes | 15 (100) |
| No | 0 (0) |
| Previous surgery, n (%) | |
| Yes | 3 (20) |
| No | 12 (80) |
The median for the ASES scale increased from a preoperative value of 34.0 to 73.0 at 12 months (p= 0.005). The UCLA scale increase from 11.0 to 27.0, the Constant-Murley from 41.0 to 73.0, and the SANE from 50.0 to 70.0 (p= 0.001, p= 0.005, and p= 0.046, respectively). The values are shown in ►Table 2.
| Median | p-value | |
|---|---|---|
| ASES | ||
| Initial | 34 | |
| 6 months | 72 | 0.008 |
| 12 months | 73 | 0.005 |
| UCLA | ||
| Initial | 11 | |
| 6 months | 24 | 0.005 |
| 12 months | 27 | 0.001 |
| Constant-Murley | ||
| Initial | 41 | |
| 6 months | 66 | 0.017 |
| 12 months | 73 | 0.005 |
| SANE | ||
| Initial | 50 | |
| 6 months | 60 | 0.231 |
| 12 months | 70 | 0.046 |
The patients presented a statistically significant difference for active range of motion in both elevation (p= 0.003) and external rotation (p= 0.007). The values are shown in ►Table 3.
| Median | p-value | |
|---|---|---|
| Elevation | ||
| Initial | 95.0 | |
| 6 months | 140.0 | 0.044 |
| 12 months | 140.0 | 0.003 |
| External rotation | ||
| Initial | 30.0 | |
| 6 months | 40.0 | 0.076 |
| 12 months | 60.0 | 0.007 |
| Internal rotation | ||
| Initial | 10.0 | |
| 6 months | 10.0 | 0.398 |
| 12 months | 10.0 | 0.624 |
There was an increase in the average acromioumeral distance from 3.62 mm (SD = 1.4) to 7.04 mm (SD = 1.6).
Graft healing occurred in 6 patients (40%) at the 6-month postoperative MRI. Among the patients without healing, there was predominance of Hamada 3 and 4 (66.7%), while among those with healing, there was a predominance of Hamada 1 and 2 (83.3%). ►Table 4 shows the distribution of the patients comparing the preoperative Hamada classification and graft healing.
| Not healed | Healed | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| n | % | n | % | |
| HAMADA | ||||
| 1 + 2 | 3 | 37.5 | 5 | 62.5 |
| 3 | 2 | 66.7 | 1 | 33.3 |
| 4 | 4 | 100.0 | 0 | 0.0 |
The subgroup analysis comparing cases with and without graft healing showed that cases with healing presented better functional results according to the ASES, UCLA and Constant-Murley scales, and the highest active elevation and internal rotation. The values are presented in ►Table 5 and ►Table 6.
| Healing | NO | YES | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean | Median | Mean | Median | p-value | |
| ASES | |||||
| Initial | 36.1 | 37.0 | 39.0 | 31.5 | 0.906 |
| 6 months | 48.1 | 43.0 | 86.5 | 90.0 | 0.003 |
| 12 months | 58.0 | 55.0 | 87.3 | 90.0 | 0.013 |
| UCLA | |||||
| Initial | 10.5 | 10.0 | 13.8 | 14.5 | 0.238 |
| 6 months | 16.1 | 15.0 | 29.3 | 30.0 | 0.011 |
| 12 months | 19.7 | 25.0 | 30.6 | 30.0 | 0.013 |
| Constant-Murley | |||||
| Initial | 38.0 | 38.0 | 54.3 | 60.5 | 0.195 |
| 6 months | 44.7 | 37.0 | 74.8 | 80.0 | 0.007 |
| 12 months | 53.3 | 65.0 | 75.1 | 78.5 | 0.011 |
| SANE | |||||
| Initial | 57.7 | 50.0 | 38.3 | 35.0 | 0.210 |
| 6 months | 53.3 | 50.0 | 80.0 | 80.0 | 0.023 |
| 12 months | 66.6 | 70.0 | 81.6 | 85.0 | 0.188 |
| Not healed | Healed | p-value | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elevation (median °) | |||
| Initial | 90 | 148 | 0.288 |
| 12 months | 133 | 175 | 0.020 |
| External rotation (median °) | |||
| Initial | 20 | 47.5 | 0.121 |
| 12 months | 60 | 67.5 | 0.159 |
| Internal rotation (median °) | |||
| Initial | 12 | 8.5 | 0.184 |
| 12 months | 13 | 7 | 0.001 |
No superficial or deep infections, neurological lesions, hematomas, or joint stiffness were reported.
DISCUSSION
Regarding the clinical outcomes, there was a statistically significant improvement in the ASES scale, with a median preoperative score of 34.0 and a 12-month score of 73.0 (p= 0.003). Although all studies show statistically significant improvements, there are some differences in the ASES scale values when compared with the others. Mihata et al.,4 using autografts, obtained excellent results with the mean ASES scale score increasing from 23.5 to 92.9 in their first published clinical study. In addition, the same authors reported similar results in other subsequently published studies.13,14 However, Pennington et al.15 and Burkhart et al.16 published promising results using decellularized human dermis, but without achieving a mean ASES scale score > 90 points (82 and 89, respectively). Similarly to our study, both Denard et al.17 and Hirahara et al.18 achieved statistically significant results with ASES scale values < 80 points (77.5 and 70.7, respectively) using dermal grafts. Improvement in all clinical scores corroborates the results presented in four recently published literature reviews.19-22
In the active range of motion assessment, there were improvements both in elevation, which increased from 95 to 140° (p= 0.003), and in external rotation, which increased from 30 to 60° (p= 0.007). Our results are in line with what has already been published regarding range of motion after SCR, both in studies that used autografts 4,13,23 and in studies that used decellularized human dermis grafts.15-18
Regarding the acromiohumeral distance, we observed a mean of 3.62 mm preoperatively and of 7.04 mm postoperatively. This finding is similar to that demonstrated in previous publications with gains that range from 2.6 to 5 mm after surgery.4,15,18
In the evaluation of graft healing after 6 months of follow-up, 6 patients (40%) presented complete healing, and 9 patients (60%) showed signs of non-healing. Similarly, in 2018, Denard et al.17 published a 45% healing rate, while AlRamadhan et al.24 and Lee et al.25 reported rates of 69.3 and 63.8%, respectively. However, Mihata et al.4,13 observed higher rates following SCR, with levels of 83.3 and 93% in studies published in 2013 and 2015. After a systematic review that evaluated a total of 350 cases, Catapano et al.19 reported a graft healing rate of 87.5%, a finding similar to the rate of 85.8% published by Sochacki et al.,20 also in a systematic review.
When we correlated the graft healing rate with the preoperative Hamada classification, we observed that of the 9 non-healing patients, 6 (66.7%) were classified as Hamada 3 or 4, while 83.3% of the healing patients were classified as Hamada 1 or 2. Although our sample was small, which diminishes the power of the results, our data corroborate with Denard et al.,17 who published a healing rate of 75% in Hamada 1 and 2 patients and of only 44% in patients classified as Hamada 3 or 4. These data may help us understand the high healing rates published by Mihata et al. (83.3%),4 given that only 2 patients in his series of 24 cases were classified as Hamada 3 or 4.
When we evaluated the clinical scores by “healing” and “non-healing” subgroups, we observed that they did not present any preoperative statistical difference. However, at the 12-month follow-up, all scores were statistically higher in the healing group, except for the SANE scale. Similar to the findings described by Denard et al.,17 who published an ASES mean score of 90.0 in patients with graft healing versus 66.5 in non-healing cases (p= 0.027). We also observed a statistically significant difference in the evaluation of active elevation, with a median of 175° in the healed subgroup versus 133° in the unhealed subgroup (p= 0.020), a finding similar to that published by Mihata et al.13 These data suggest that the preoperative Hamada classification may assist in the prognosis and indication of the SCR procedure. Frank et al.,26 in a literature review, suggested that only patients classified as Hamada 1 and 2 are candidates for SCR, and our study corroborates this suggestion.
As limitations, we can highlight the fact that the present study was noncomparative, with a relatively small sample and short follow-up. However, the sample size is within the average range of the other studies,4,16,18 and the follow-up time was similar to that published in earlier studies.15-18,24 In addition, another limitation was the lateral fixation of the graft performed with the single-row technique. However, good results were achieved with the single-row technique, especially in patients with Hamada classification 1 or 2.24,25
Even though it has shown satisfactory initial results, SCR is a relatively recent procedure. Further clinical studies are needed to confirm its long-term effectiveness and define the type of patient for this surgery. In addition, the ideal graft and its fixation method also need to be defined.
CONCLUSION
Superior capsular reconstruction with allograft fascia lata is a safe procedure that provides clinical improvement to patients. Better results are shown in cases where complete healing of the graft occurs.
